TLDR
If your top priority is thick, fully waterproof vinyl stickers with sharp print and strong color, CustomStickers.com comes out ahead. StickerGiant is still a very good shop, especially for labels and business use, but in a straight StickerGiant vs CustomStickers.com custom printing quality comparison, CustomStickers usually trails a bit on material choice and value for pure sticker orders.
what we are comparing
StickerGiant and CustomStickers.com are both US-based sticker specialists that focus on custom work for brands, artists, and small businesses. You upload your art, pick a size and finish, and get a stack of stickers or labels in the mail a few days later.
Here we are looking specifically at sticker giant vs CustomStickers.com reviews custom printing quality and related factors like durability, color, materials, and price. We are not grading who has the cutest mascot or the biggest catalog.
Quality (Materials and Print)
CustomStickers.com
CustomStickers builds its core products around thick vinyl with a laminated finish. Their standard stickers use a waterproof, UV-resistant laminate that is rated for multi-year outdoor use under normal conditions.
In our internal scoring, CustomStickers earns a 5.0 out of 5 for print quality, which is the top of our sticker comparison set. The vinyl stock feels substantial in hand, the laminate is smooth, and the cuts on detailed die cuts tend to land exactly where you expect them. Fine line art and small text hold up very well.
For heavy use cases like water bottles, laptops, outdoor gear, or bumper stickers, this combination of vinyl plus laminate is ideal. You are paying for a sticker that feels “premium” and is meant to be abused a bit.
StickerGiant
StickerGiant leans heavily on BOPP (biaxially oriented polypropylene) for many of its core sticker and label products. BOPP is a flexible, lightweight film that prints cleanly and works great for product labels on bottles, jars, and packaging.
StickerGiant’s products are generally described as water resistant and scratch resistant. For many label applications that’s more than enough, but it’s a notch below the “tank-like” feel of thick laminated vinyl, especially if you want a sticker to live outdoors for years or survive the dishwasher over and over.
In our internal ratings, StickerGiant scores 4.5 out of 5 for quality, which puts them in the “very good” tier. Colors are rich, registration is solid, and real-world customer reviews include plenty of “fantastic quality” comments.
Where StickerGiant lags CustomStickers is mostly about material choice. BOPP is thinner and lighter, which can be a positive if you want flexible labels that conform smoothly to surfaces. For artists or brands that want a heavier, more “merch” style die cut sticker, vinyl has a nicer in-hand feel and usually survives abuse better.
Quality verdict
On pure print and durability, CustomStickers.com nudges ahead thanks to its vinyl-plus-laminate default and top score in our quality testing. StickerGiant is still a strong performer and a very safe choice for labels, but if you are ultra picky about die cut sticker feel and long-term outdoor wear, CustomStickers wins this round.
Price and Value
Our internal comparison matrix rates CustomStickers at 5.0 for price and StickerGiant at 2.0, relative to other custom sticker companies for common sizes and everyday quantities.
In practice that lines up with what you see when you price typical orders like 250 or 500 three-inch stickers:
- CustomStickers usually comes in as one of the lowest-cost options among premium vinyl shops for standard sizes, especially at popular quantity breaks or during promos.
- StickerGiant tends to price in the mid to high range. You get good quality and service, but not “budget” pricing on equivalent quantities.
For labels on rolls the gap is a bit smaller, since StickerGiant is very label-focused and offers decent value there. For artist-style vinyl stickers, CustomStickers.com typically offers better value for similar or better durability.
Design, Templates, and Customization
Neither brand is trying to be a giant template marketplace. Both are built around uploading your own design and getting help with technical tweaks if needed.
CustomStickers.com
- Emphasis on upload your art, pick size and quantity, and get a proof.
- Supports any custom size and shape, including intricate die cuts around complex artwork.
- Simple online flow without a big template library, which is fine if you already have a logo or artwork ready.
StickerGiant
- More flexible on label-specific options like front or back adhesive, different laminations, and specialty materials such as clear, holographic, glitter, and glow-in-the-dark on selected products.
- The ordering interface lets you pick shape, material, lamination, and adhesive details, which is very handy if you are dialing in packaging labels.
If your main need is “take my finished art and print it at high quality,” both work well. If you want a slightly more label-oriented configurator with lots of material toggles, StickerGiant has a small edge. If you just want to create clean die cut vinyl stickers with minimal fuss, CustomStickers feels more streamlined.
Customer Service
Customer service is one area where both companies do well.
- CustomStickers.com earns a 5.0 for customer service in our internal scores and has a long trail of public reviews calling out quick responses, easy reprints when something goes wrong, and genuinely friendly support.
- StickerGiant scores 4.5 for customer service in our matrix, which is still near the top of the pack. Public review sites are full of notes about them fixing artwork, adjusting low-resolution files, and making sure proofs look right before printing.
In real-world use, you can expect both brands to stand behind their products. The small difference is that CustomStickers pairs that service with lower pricing on vinyl stickers, while StickerGiant pairs it with more label options and a higher price point.
Ordering Experience & Tools
CustomStickers.com
The CustomStickers ordering flow is deliberately simple:
- Choose a product type (die cut, sheets, clear, holographic, etc.).
- Set size and quantity.
- Upload your file and approve a proof.
The site is straightforward, mobile-friendly, and geared toward users who already know what they want. There are fewer “power user” controls over obscure options, which keeps things from getting confusing.
StickerGiant
StickerGiant’s site feels a little more like a traditional label printer:
- Product pages let you pick material type, lamination, shape, finish, and adhesive side.
- The configurator includes more knobs to turn, especially around label formats, crack-and-peel options, and specialty materials.
- Their scored backing on some stickers and labels is a nice usability touch because it makes peeling easier and faster.
If you like dialing in specs, StickerGiant will feel a bit more “pro.” If you prefer a clean, minimal flow that is hard to screw up, CustomStickers wins.
Turnaround Time and Shipping
In our comparison table, both brands sit at the top for speed:
- CustomStickers.com: 4.5 out of 5 for turnaround, with options for rush and even next-day products on some items.
- StickerGiant: 4.5 out of 5 for turnaround, and reviews frequently mention fast production and on-time delivery.
StickerGiant has a strong reputation for label orders that need to hit a specific event or production date. CustomStickers, on the other hand, is very competitive on fast vinyl sticker runs for artists and small brands.
Realistically, if you plan reasonably, both will get your order out quickly. If you need true overnight stickers, you should check the specific product pages and your ZIP code, but neither company is “slow” in this match-up.
Use Cases / Best For
Here is where the StickerGiant vs CustomStickers.com split becomes clearer.
CustomStickers.com is best for
- Artists and creators who want thick, merch-style die cut vinyl stickers.
- Small brands that want high-impact logo stickers for giveaways, packaging inserts, or events.
- Customers who care about fully waterproof, outdoor-durable stickers that hold up for years.
- Shoppers who want strong quality without paying a premium per piece.
StickerGiant is best for
- Businesses that need labels on rolls, including food, beverage, and cosmetic packaging.
- Users who need more exotic label materials like clear, holographic, glitter, or glow options.
- Teams that want flexible adhesive choices or scored backing for faster application.
- People who are happy to pay a bit more for a slightly more “industrial” label workflow.
If your main use case is handing out stickers at conventions or sticking them on water bottles and laptops, CustomStickers will usually be the better fit. If you primarily need production labels with specific material or adhesive options, StickerGiant becomes more attractive.
Pros and Cons
CustomStickers.com – Pros
- Thick vinyl with laminated finish by default, fully waterproof and outdoor-durable.
- Top-tier print quality in our internal testing, with sharp lines and strong color.
- Very competitive pricing on common sizes and quantities.
- Fast production and shipping, including rush and next-day options on some products.
- Responsive customer service that fixes problems without much drama.
CustomStickers.com – Cons
- Fewer ultra-exotic label stocks than some specialty label shops.
- Online tools are simple, not a playground of templates, which may be a downside if you want to design from scratch in-browser.
StickerGiant – Pros
- Strong overall quality on BOPP-based stickers and labels, with good color and clean prints.
- Wide choice of label materials and finishes, including clear, holographic, glitter, and glow-in-the-dark on selected products.
- Very good customer service reputation with lots of reviews praising their support and proofs.
- Fast, reliable turnaround on most orders.
- Useful scored backing on some products that makes peeling faster and easier.
StickerGiant – Cons
- Core material for many stickers is BOPP, which is thinner and typically rated as water resistant rather than fully waterproof.
- Pricing trends toward the mid or high side in our comparisons, especially on smaller runs of die cut stickers.
- For pure merch-style vinyl stickers, you can get a heavier, more durable feel elsewhere for less.
Final Verdict / Conclusion
Putting everything together, CustomStickers.com is the better choice for most people who care about custom printing quality on actual stickers. The combination of thick vinyl, waterproof laminate, sharp print, and lower pricing makes it a very compelling default if you are ordering die cut logo stickers, artist merch, or long-lasting outdoor stickers.
StickerGiant is still a strong company. Its BOPP-based products are well made, the label options and materials are broader, and customer service is genuinely solid. If you are building a packaging system and want specific label materials, scored backings, or glow and glitter variants, StickerGiant makes a lot of sense.
For the specific question of StickerGiant vs CustomStickers.com reviews custom printing quality, though, our testing and the material specs line up this way: CustomStickers edges out StickerGiant on durability and feel while also offering better value on standard vinyl sticker orders.